Debate > Research
THBT animal testing should be abolished
Page 1 / 1
THBT animal testing should be abolished
04/05/2011 7:38 am

Junior Member


Regist.: 04/05/2011
Topics: 1
Posts: 8
OFFLINE
Story of Liam

8888884. I just got those numbers tattooed on myself. They are numbers that mean a lot to me because I am not the first person to get them. These numbers were first tattooed on someone nearly four years ago. Someone who didn't get to choose where he would get his number. Someone who didn't want a number in the first place. His name is Liam. He's my dog.

For the first four years of Liam's life, he didn't have a name. He was a laboratory testing animal and as such, a name wasn't in the cards for him. A name would have personalized him. Made him real. Turned him into something more than the subject of an experiment, a tool to be used for human gain. It makes it harder to view a person as a thing when it has a name. A series of numbers says the opposite of a name. It denotes a lack of importance; it strips a living creature of its worth and makes it just a thing that is being used. Because that's what Liam was to the people who had him for the first four years of his life. A thing. A tool. Nothing more than a number.

People sometimes ask me how I can know that. How I can know what it was like for Liam in the lab? I know because I was the first person to see him when he came out. When Liam came to live with me, he was terrified. Not just of his new surroundings, but of everything. The sound of metal clinking, the feel of grass or anything soft -- it all scared him. The thing that broke my heart most was that he was afraid of me as well. When I touched him, he would put his head down and put his tail between his legs. The only touch he had known had been the touch that was always followed by something painful. Something unpleasant. I could see it in his eyes when I touched him, he was afraid of what I was going to do to him. Afraid that myself and my friends would treat him exactly how all the other humans he had ever encountered had. As a thing. A tool. Nothing more than a number.

But he proved himself to be stronger than I can even begin to understand. Somehow, even after everything he went through, slowly but surely, he began to trust the new people around him. He started to wag his tail. To learn that there was more to this world than pain, cages and concrete. The grass still scared him, but he wanted to be near the new people around him. So he would take one big jump into the yard to be next to us and then one big jump back to the sidewalk. Over time, he didn't have to jump, he would simply walk through the grass. He had learned not to be afraid of the feel of something soft. He even learned how to play ... sort of.

In preparation for getting him from the lab, my friends and I got tons of toys for Liam -- toys we quickly learned he didn't understand or care about. We would throw a toy for him and he would just watch, unsure what was going on. He had never played before and didn't have a clue what we wanted him to do. I remember vividly the first time he chased a toy. I got so excited and he saw it. He ran to the toy, picked it up, dropped it halfway back and ran into me, knocking me over. He looked so happy. We threw it again and he would run to where it fell, leave it there, run back and bowl me over again and again in his excitement to be playing for the very first time. Watching him running back and forth through the house, wagging his tail and literally jumping into my arms remains one of the happiest moments in my life because I know it was one of the first happy moments in his. That memory still brings tears to my eyes.

To me, this tattoo is first and foremost about Liam. About someone I love and who constantly gives me the strength to not give up in the face of odds that nearly always seem insurmountable. But its about more than just Liam. Because Liam, despite all he has gone through, is one of the lucky few. The end of his ordeal was the beginning of something better. Millions of other animals in laboratories around the world and billions of other animal in exploitative industries don't get a new beginning. Only an end. Liam reminds me of that every day. Because he got a chance the vast majority of them will never get. Its of them I think when I want to give up fighting. How Liam is getting the chance they all deserve. My dog, who I love more than anything, is no different then any of them. The only difference between him and them, is he got the chance to become something more than a number.


source: http://cinematicpassions.wordpress.com/2010/08/24/animal-testing-needs-to-be-abolished-permanently/
Quote   
04/05/2011 7:53 am

NEWBIE


Regist.: 04/05/2011
Topics: 0
Posts: 8
OFFLINE
Grozno!
Quote   
04/05/2011 9:24 am

Junior Member


Regist.: 04/05/2011
Topics: 1
Posts: 8
OFFLINE
Agreed!   ...but there is still one thing bothering me... what if the animals could or would speak the same language as people do and could communicate the same way as we do, would people still torture them? I mean...would they even be able to? If they understood all the crys and begs for mercy? People would never hurt people in that way (speking of those who have a little humanity in them), why would they go and do such despicable things to animals(if they understood them)?! Why do people think that if they are able to make big buildings and other massive infrastructure etc that they are better that other animals? We are just as living and breathing and fragile as a bunny or a rat or a big giant dinosauros that lived milions of years ago, we arent different, we just communicate and function different in our society that animals do in theirs. So WHY do we have more rights than a bunny - rabbit, and why should we decide whether an animal of any kind should live or not or whether an animal should injected with a drug that could be fatal for them or not etc.  Just because we don't understand them we shouldn't take the right to do whatever we please with them WE/people DON'T have that kind of a right! We just took matters in our own hands and gave ourselves this ''RIGHT'', and that is just wrong! Even if we don't understand them they still cry, even if we don't know what their feeling they still feel, and they lived, are living and will still be living and breathing on the same place in a similar way as people do....etc  

These are just a couple opinions of mine, I could still go on(maybe some other time), but I am really looking forward to hear/read yours.  
Quote   
04/05/2011 9:46 am

Junior Member


Regist.: 04/05/2011
Topics: 1
Posts: 8
OFFLINE
http://www.peta.org/tv/videos/animal-experimentation/326096933001.aspx
Quote   
04/05/2011 3:28 pm

Administrator
Cool Senior Member


Regist.: 04/02/2011
Topics: 13
Posts: 29
OFFLINE
A word of caution if you research this topic. If you are going to watch the videos be aware of the fact that some material can be deeply disturbing.
Quote   
04/06/2011 8:02 am

NEWBIE


Regist.: 04/05/2011
Topics: 0
Posts: 8
OFFLINE
I agree with you, Anja. But what if we hadn't done the tests on animals?? We wouldn't have found all the cures, drugs and treatments for us to use. I'm sure you agree with me that any sane human wouldn't volunteer to be tested on, except if their economic state would force them to do it for money. I guess (as I have said it a million times last thursday ) this is for a greater good (is this the right phrase?). If there wasn't animal testing, we would be still dying of colds, pneumonia or as I saw it on House M.D. series yesterday, angioedema . I know it sound horrible, but I am still for animal testing.
But that's just my opinion.
Quote   
04/06/2011 11:46 am

Junior Member


Regist.: 04/05/2011
Topics: 1
Posts: 8
OFFLINE
In my research I acctually read that a LOT of test that pass on animals don't actually work on humans or/and the effect on humans can be fatal(and there have already been these worse case scenarios!). I am not suggesting that we start to experiment on humans (no way that would be as despicable as testing on animals), I am just saying that we(as evolved as we are supposed to be) should try it on a different level of science...they can and do grow organs in labs now, why not make synthetic skin while your at it. And I am sure that ways that would be less painfull for animals are NOW possible but ''someone who has the greater power in the world'', doesn't want to put the secret out, because testing on animals would be/ or is cheaper.
And I am not saying that it was all bad in the past, but as far as my research goes it's not doing any good anymore(it's deteriorating as we speak, because were trying more complex drugs on them and even the bodys of primates aren't compadable to the human body at this point (for example: why is there still no cure for cancar or HIV, there have been thousands and thousands of experimants done on monkeys for that???)...
Quote   
04/06/2011 1:03 pm

NEWBIE


Regist.: 04/05/2011
Topics: 0
Posts: 8
OFFLINE
I do agree with your last paragraph. (I'm making a paradox now. ) Testing on animals is no longer efficient. But I don't know. If we make an artificial organ, you still won't see what the drug does to your other body parts. For an example, I was taking an antibiotic for my throat infection and i got a rash on the back of my legs as a side effect. You can't see what happens to the whole body when you apply a drug on a certain part of the body. Cloning could be presented as an alternative though, but that is unfortunately immoral.

I have found so many contradictions in this topic that I get a headache, when I'm trying to declare what my opinion is. It's so difficult, because when I find something I would agree with and say: "Finally!", I find a reason to oppose it.  

So I agree and disagree with you in certain angles of the topic.
Quote   
04/06/2011 4:24 pm

Administrator
Cool Senior Member


Regist.: 04/02/2011
Topics: 13
Posts: 29
OFFLINE
That's what I say you chose a very good resolution to debate. Why? Because there ARE at least valid if not very good arguments for as well as against the resolution.
Still it would be wrong to conclude that this means everything is relative and it does no longer matter. The exact opposite is true. In order to be able to take sides (or remain ambiguous) one needs to explore all that is relevant and important in a given matter.
Proud of you !
Quote   
Page 1 / 1
Login with Facebook to post
Preview