OFFLINE

This is the Tang Soo Do Moo Duk Kwan General Federations Hwa Sun Hyung not to be confused by GM Hang Kee's Hwa Sun Hyung which is his interpretation from the Moo Yei Do Bo Tong Ji and is only similar in name.

OFFLINE

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=npi-myr23XA&feature=player_embedded


What about this one SBN Segerra..

OFFLINE

That's the federation version of Hwang Kee's Hwa Sun.

OFFLINE

So they've finally started letting this out into the open. I think I liked the version published in Vol 2.  a bit better.

OFFLINE

The version in volume 2 is weird. It does not gel with the MYDBTJ. There is no way GM Hwang Kee came up with this and here's why. They scrapped it. And the NEVER would scrap some hyung he created. So it's a really strange form.

The newer version gels very well with the MYDBTJ so that's the one they should stay with.

OFFLINE

I was just giving personal opinions of how I felt watching it. My aesthetics clearly are biased; I personally didn't like watching this version. I'm just learning the first five chil sung hyung (my org does not do the last two) and my original TSD training is more external and has strong japanese influences. I might have a different opinion if I saw a better performance, just my gut reaction.

OFFLINE

Well the interesting thing about Hwa Sun 2 is it is almost identical to the demo of GM Hwang Kee in atlantic city nj. So obviously this is the refined version of that. It is definitely a different 'energy' a more grounded type of style.

OFFLINE

I just don't have the experience yet to appreciate it. Maybe it's like scotch... Now I'm thirsty.