OFFLINE

Numeric ratings on a 10 point scale ranging from a waste of money up to retail quality.

http://printplaygames.com/
Custom Size quadfold board - 7
The cuts were not as clean along the inside as I might have liked and this led to some bunching or folding but the color was great, the board was good weight and they have been used many times with little appreciable wear.  The edges do not have the binding tape that you find on a traditional board but they are absolutely superb for a pitch-able promo.

1" Diameter 4c/- tokens- 9
I was very impressed with the tokens.  The colors were clean and standardized.  The cuts were clean and the tokens looked great.  The only thing that kept it from being a 10 was that I felt the variance on the die cuts had a little more error than I would like.  Considering how bad some punch outs are though these might well be 10 worthy.  I don't recall there being an option for different finishes, but the standard, matte I think, that they came in was great.  As with the board they have been used in many play tests with no appreciable wear.

Over all I think that Print & Play Productions is a great company to work with.  Their communication was superb and they have a lot of customizable options.  I see that they have a section for printed games so it is possible that there is a premium service available that we didn't need because we were just making prototypes.